It was the countrys good fortune that it had both men and could, in time, fuse and reconcile their philosophies. Stanford history education group reading like a hisprian alexander hamilton letter to george washington. Alexander hamilton vs thomas jefferson chart thomas. Read the information about jefferson and hamiltons differing views about government. Difference between hamilton and jefferson compare the. The first two party system due 2618 george washington, unbound by considerations of party, put together a geographically and ideologically diverse cabinet that was dominated by alexander hamilton, the secretary of the treasury, and.
Unfortunately, george washington thought theyd be great together and put hamilton as his secretary of the treasury and jefferson as secretary of state. Two letters to george washington allow students to consider the competing politics and personalities of thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton. Jefferson also believed that the constitution did not give the. Thomas jefferson vs alexander hamilton ap us history youtube. Hamilton, who was always ahead of the curve, tells jefferson why the newly formed united states needs a treasury and centralized government in the hbo miniseries, john adams. Using the information in the documents and your general knowledge of the two men, analyze the debates between them, their respective positions, that each represented. Although alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were two great leaders in united states history, they both had very different views of government and of the economy. On the other hand, jeffersons philosophy differed in the sense that it was more inclined towards the weak central government. Hamilton expressed dissatisfaction with both of the plans brought forward to the convention. The people are turbulent and changing, he wrote in 1787, they seldom judge or determine right. Answer this in a complete sentence somewhere on your note sheet 2. The careers of hamilton and jefferson were among the most interesting in. It wasnt until hamiltons economic policy began to take shape in late 1791 and 1792 that each man took a closer look at the other and began to wonder about what he saw. Sep 04, 2018 hamiltons economic vision was contrary to that of jeffersons, and as such the united states might not have movedor at least not moved as quicklyin the direction of becoming a.
It ended only with the death of hamilton in a pistol duel, felled by aaron burr, jefferson s vice president. Hamilton, a brilliant organizer and tactician, feared chaos and social disorder. At this time, 90% of all americans made a living off of agriculture rather than industry. A modern perspective on hamilton and jefferson ideaexchange.
Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both appointed to george washingtons cabinet. Polar opposites hamilton even jefferson thought that the u. In order to make manufacturing big and get rid of agriculture he proposed the whiskey tax that upset southern farmers that made whiskey. Roosevelt more hamiltonian or jeffersonian in his approach toward trusts. Hamilton believed that we should remain neutral to all foreign affairs especially the french revolution because we dont have the resources to fight in the war.
Hamilton, jefferson, and the first national bank of the united states magine going to a bank to borrow money. Hamilton vs jefferson free essay example studymoose. Pdf damien theillier jefferson vs hamilton ic damien. Thomas jefferson unlike hamilton, thomas jefferson was an aristocrat by birth and a democrat by conviction.
Jefferson and hamilton, political rivals george washington. National bank was created by the efforts of hamilton, and this was criticized by jefferson. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The conflict that took shape in the 1790s between the federalists and the antifederalists exercised a profound impact on american history. A system of taxes through a tariff on imports was the chief point that hamilton insisted. Indeed, the federalists, led by alexander hamilton, and the republicans also called democraticrepublicans, led by thomas jefferson, were the first political parties in the western world. It ended only with the death of hamilton in a pistol duel, felled by aaron burr, jeffersons vice president. This is a brief introduction to the conflicts between thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton during the washington administration that led to. John adams sided with the federalists in spite of some personal and political disagreements with hamilton, while jefferson was joined by his close friend, james madison. Some of the nations founders, like alexander hamilton, believed in a strong central government while others shared the sentiments of thomas jefferson that the states should dominate the political system. Comparing the ideals of hamilton and jefferson 1 dlrections. Hamilton accepted when burr challenged him to a duel. Stanford history education group reading like a hisprian alexander.
Hamilton believed that industry was the way to go in order to make america have more power. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson a more perfect union. The first two party system due 2618 george washington, unbound by considerations of party, put together a geographically and ideologically diverse cabinet that was dominated by alexander hamilton, the secretary of the treasury, and thomas jefferson, the secretary of state. Complete tm chart below tor the hlsloncal figure your group created a poster about. Hamilton federalist jefferson democraticrepublican edl.
Hbo john adams alexander hamilton takes jefferson to. Sep 20, 2011 national bank was created by the efforts of hamilton, and this was criticized by jefferson. Hamilton believed that the common people of america often acted foolishly, while jefferson had a lot of faith in common people such as farmers. Pdf this article describes how institutions get infused with competing logics and analyzes how such competing logics might aid the design of. Hbo john adams alexander hamilton takes jefferson to school. Jefferson, by contrast, had supreme faith in the electorate and wished to guarantee the survival of liberty by improving the education of the common people. Oct 04, 2008 hamilton, who was always ahead of the curve, tells jefferson why the newly formed united states needs a treasury and centralized government in the hbo miniseries, john adams. Oct 12, 2014 this is a brief introduction to the conflicts between thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton during the washington administration that led to the formation of the first two party system in the.
Hamilton and jefferson document based question american history grade 11 regular. Alexander hamilton, one of the most important people of the time, was the first secretary of the treasury. Read the psten the other groups made md recod your findings on the chart low i. Hamilton feared anarchy and thought in terms of order. President george washington had two strong willed men in his administration. Hamilton presented a strict, narrow presented a lose, broad construction. Heres a brief summary of the two positions, if youre interested. Wanted to create a national bank to provide loans for businessmen, and to provide a place to deposit federal funds.
Chapter 2 hamilton and jefferson the men and their philosophies. Hamilton younger than jefferson by 12 years did not trust the general public. He died with burrs bullet in his chest in weehawken, new jersey, on july 12, 1804. Hamiltons economic vision was contrary to that of jeffersons, and as such the united states might not have movedor at least not moved as quicklyin the direction of becoming a. He believed that merchants, manufacturers, financiers, lawyers. Pdf balancing hamiltonian and jeffersonian contradictions. Although hamilton and jefferson contemplated issues related to the governance. Jefferson and hamilton is the story of the fierce struggleboth public and, ultimately, bitterly personalbetween these two titans. Chapter 4 hamilton, jefferson, and the first national. Chapter 4 hamilton, jefferson, and the first national bank.
He thought that commercialization, centralization, and industrialization would lead to many problems for the country in the future. The conflict that took shape in the 1790s between the federalists and the antifederalists exercised a profound impact on american. Hamilton, a staunch federalist, and jefferson with his agrarian democracy, could not agree on much in regards to the structure and role of government. The graphic organizer presents the information side by side in their own words and then extends the learning by having students apply what they have learned to a series of evi. Both had a vision for america, but they were diametrically different. At age 14, the young jefferson inherited his fathers plantation and slaves. To evaluate the major events and developments during our early presidencies and to determine how divided political views and the war of 1812 shaped america this is an. Hamilton lead the federalist people for the constitution while jefferson lead the antifederalist people against the constitution or believed that the constitution did not fully protect the.
Hamilton and jefferson document based question american history grade 11 regular levei courtney firebaogh, auburndaie high. Hamilton confrontations that shaped a nation first edition 2000 noble e. Interweaving more than 40 documents into 7 chronological chapters, the text follows the lives and careers of the two men from their youth, through the revolutionary war, to the death of hamilton in 1804. Washington concerned about the constitutionality of the united states bank, asked jefferson and hamilton each to give their opinions on the. Utilizing federal power to modernize the nation, he convinced congress to use an elastic interpretation of the constitution to pass laws that jefferson deemed unconstitutional.
On the other hand, jeffersons philosophy differed in the sense that it. The virginia plan, which was a proposal to completely abandon the articles of confederation, and replace it with a bicameral national legislature, an executive. Nov 06, 20 thomas jefferson vs alexander hamilton, one of the chief rivalries at the center of american politics through the first two decades, split the nation by ideology and purpose. Questions for discussion could be posed throughout the year, such as. Jefferson alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both important founding fathers in the early days of the american nation, yet they despised each other. Article i, section 8 of the constitution allows congress. Alexander hamilton vs thomas jefferson chart thomas jefferson. American foreign policy suggests that jefferson, not hamilton, did unswervingly apply as standard the national interest of the united states. A conflict took shape in the 1790s between americas first political parties. Whose vision of america won outhamiltons or jeffersons.
Bell ringer why did many people oppose the economic plan of alexander hamilton. Jefferson, hamilton and american foreign policy jstor. According to the philosophy of hamilton, more and more powers should be given to the federal government. He thought states should charter banks that could issue money. Jefferson debate has been going on for two centuries, and will probably continue through the life of the nation. Political parties began to form around jefferson s and hamilton s views of the constitution. Teacher materials and student materials updated on 112818. Hamilton favored a strong, active, and energetic central government, while jefferson advocated for a limited federal government that would respect the rights of the states. Hamilton occasionally asked for jeffersons opinions, and jefferson nominated hamilton for membership in the american philosophical society. It wasnt until hamilton s economic policy began to take shape in late 1791 and 1792 that each man took a closer look at the other and began to wonder about what he saw. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both appointed to george washingtons cabinet, despite differing opinions on the role of the government. Chapter 2 hamilton and jefferson the men and their. On the other hand, hamilton attacked the theory of jefferson when it comes to the limitation of the powers of the federal government. Thomas jefferson vs alexander hamilton, one of the chief rivalries at the center of american politics through the first two decades, split the nation by ideology and purpose.
Thomas jefferson to george washington, may 23, 1792 and alexander hamilton to edward carrington, may 26, 1792 in jefferson vs. Amh201008 february 22, 20 the country of the united states had many contributing factors to become what it is today. Jefferson and their oppositions jennifer maine american history to 1865. Opposite of hamilton, jefferson believed that agricultural was the best economic support for the county over industrialization. Their competing legacies, like the twin strands of dna, continue to shape our country to this day. Hamiltons vision could be highlighted in three points as follows. At the end of the american revolution, two political philosophies dominated american politics. Textbooks may offer helpful summaries of historical figures lives and contributions, but rarely do they capture a sense of their personalities. Engaging with the two positions helps us clarify our own beliefs about what the united states is and should be. Alexander hamilton, born in the caribbean to a single mother, had worked his way up to become the first treasury. He sought to build a powerful national government that could ensure the young nations security and drive it toward economic greatness. Jefferson feared tyranny and thought in terms of freedom. The federalists, led by alexander hamilton, who had married into the wealthy schuyler family, represented the urban mercantile interests of the seaports.
This is a minilesson on hamilton and jefferson that looks at the views of these famous founding fathers in their own words. This documentary study of thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton focuses on their differing views of society and government in the formative years of the new american nation. Jefferson, thomas, 17431826, hamilton, alexander, 17571804 publisher boston. Believed that america should have a strong commercial society with a large industrial sector. To evaluate the major events and developments during our early presidencies and to determine how divided political views and the war of 1812 shaped america.
190 1008 118 498 1659 407 1040 165 1576 1239 1400 602 839 960 62 1038 1196 1105 890 673 1434 792 344 17 449 1171 153 1540 1136 1611 1044 840 1481 907 764 1372 1069 1531 1428 5 884 967 1044 420 1087 1340 386